Where to Dine Like a Local: The Best Restaurants & Happy Hour Spots in Sanibel, Fort Myers & Cape Coral

Discover the best local restaurants and happy hour spots in Sanibel, Fort Myers, and Cape Coral. From fresh seafood to sunset cocktails, here’s where Southwest Florida locals eat, drink, and unwind after a day on the water.

From the Water to the Table — Dining Local with Saltwater Todd

If you’ve ever fished with Saltwater Todd, you know Southwest Florida is more than just a destination — it’s a way of life. The same passion that drives a sunrise tarpon run fuels the local food scene, where the flavors are fresh, the drinks are cold, and the views are pure Gulf Coast gold.

After a day spent casting for redfish, snook, or tarpon, there’s no better way to wind down than with great food, good company, and a true local atmosphere. Below is a hand-picked list of restaurants and happy hour spots in Sanibel, Fort Myers, and Cape Coral — all local favorites that capture the easygoing, coastal spirit of Southwest Florida.

Top Restaurants & Happy Hour Spots on Sanibel Island

Bleu Rendezvous Bistro – French Flair on Island Time

A cozy Sanibel restaurant offering French-inspired dishes and an intimate atmosphere. Locals love Bleu Rendezvous for its curated wine list, romantic setting, and perfectly prepared entrées. Ideal for date night or a relaxed evening after fishing the flats.

Cielo – Upscale Dining with a Sanibel Twist

Cielo blends fine dining with that laid-back Sanibel attitude. The craft cocktails and live piano music make it one of the best happy hour spots in Sanibel. Don’t miss their fresh seafood and creative seasonal menu.

Courtney’s Continental Cuisine – Hidden Gem of Sanibel

Tucked away on Periwinkle Way, Courtney’s Continental Cuisine serves up steak, seafood, and pasta with a family-run touch. It’s one of those local restaurants in Sanibel that keeps regulars coming back for consistent quality and friendly service.

Best Fort Myers Restaurants & Bars with Happy Hour

Bellini’s – Italian Comfort with a Local Feel

Known for warm service and generous pours, Bellini’s offers authentic Italian food in a relaxed, tucked-away setting. The happy hour in Fort Myers here is one of the area’s best-kept secrets.

La Fontanella – A Fort Myers Classic

La Fontanella is where locals go for homemade pasta, veal piccata, and a perfectly poured glass of wine. A long-standing favorite that delivers authentic Italian cuisine in Fort Myers with timeless charm.

The Veranda – Historic Southern Charm

Located in downtown Fort Myers, The Veranda brings old Florida to life with Southern-inspired cuisine and tropical courtyard dining. It’s a must-visit for anyone seeking fine dining in Fort Myers with a side of history.

Sushi Maki – Fresh, Fun & Flavorful

If you’re craving sushi after a long day on the water, Sushi Maki in Fort Myers hits the spot. Creative rolls, great prices, and a lively happy hour make it a consistent local favorite.

Waterfront Dining & Island Vibes & Cape Coral Waterfront Spots

Cabbage Key – Iconic Old Florida Experience

Arrive by boat and grab a burger at the legendary Cabbage Key Inn & Restaurant. Surrounded by mangroves and steeped in local lore, this spot serves up great food, cold drinks, and million-dollar views of Pine Island Sound. (Pro tip: it’s one of the best boating lunch spots in Southwest Florida.)

Gather – Modern Waterfront Dining

Gather combines upscale dining with a laid-back waterfront setting. With a creative menu, handcrafted cocktails, and one of the best happy hours in Cape Coral, it’s perfect for unwinding after a day on the water.

Next Door – Stylish & Social

Next Door is a newer addition to the Cape Coral dining scene, known for its shareable small plates, smart cocktails, and coastal-modern vibe. A go-to for happy hour or a relaxed dinner with friends.

Deep Lagoon Seafood – Fresh Catch & Coastal Comfort

Deep Lagoon brings the Gulf to your plate with fresh-caught fish, oysters, and a rotating seasonal menu. With locations around the area, it’s one of the most reliable seafood restaurants in Southwest Florida for both locals and visitors.

Mcgregor Cafe - Lunch Hot Spot

Sit outside on their patio and enjoy fresh breakfast/lunch items. It's a great spot to grab quick bite to eat and enjoy classic fort myers vibes.

Eat, Drink & Live the Local Life

From Sanibel Island to Cape Coral, these restaurants showcase the best of Southwest Florida’s flavor. Whether you’re chasing tarpon at sunrise or watching the sunset over the Gulf, you’ll find great meals, cold drinks, and friendly faces at these local gems.

If you’re looking to experience the area the way locals do — both on the water and at the table — book a fishing charter with Saltwater Todd and make a full day of it. Catch your adventure in the morning, and taste the coast by evening.